British government on sanctions over Tigray war say it “will consider the full range of policy tools at our disposal.”

Source: Lord David Alton

Government Questioned Today about massacre at Axum in Tigray, and allegations of crimes against humanity. In written replies it says it is unable to “verify reports that this includes the transfer of military equipment and money by the Government of Ethiopia to the Government of Eritrea”; “condemns the destruction of the Hitsats and Shimbella refugee camps in Tigray” and forced return of refugees would contravene the 1951 Refugee Convention; and says ” We are keeping the provision of aid to Ethiopia under constant review.”

Mar 9, 2021 | Featured parliamentary activity

Government Questioned Today about massacre at Axum in Tigray, and allegations of crimes against humanity. In written replies it says it is unable to “verify reports that this includes the transfer of military equipment and money by the Government of Ethiopia to the Government of Eritrea”; “condemns the destruction of the Hitsats and Shimbella refugee camps in Tigray” and forced return of refugees would contravene the 1951 Refugee Convention; and says ” We are keeping the provision of aid to Ethiopia under constant review.”

Question12.42pm

Asked byLord Alton of Liverpool 

To ask Her Majesty’s Government what assessment they have made of reports of a massacre at Axum in Tigray, which Amnesty International said may amount to crimes against humanity.

Lord Alton of Liverpool (CB)

My Lords, I beg leave to ask the Question standing in my name on the Order Paper. In doing so, I declare my interest as a vice-chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Eritrea.The Minister of State, Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon) (Con)

My Lords, we believe that the allegations about human rights violations in the Amnesty report are credible. Over recent weeks, multiple reports, including from Human Rights Watch and the Ethiopian Human Rights Commission, have begun to document the scale of possible abuses and human rights violations in Tigray. Since the conflict started, the UK has called consistently for an end to the fighting, and I reiterate those calls today, as well as the need for urgent independent investigations into the atrocities in Tigray in order to end impunity.

Lord Alton of Liverpool (CB)

My Lords, I thank the Minister for that reply. With vast numbers of Tigrayans having been displaced and 4 million now facing a manmade famine, reports from Amnesty and Human Rights Watch underline the allegations of crimes against humanity at Axum and allegations of an unfolding genocide. What are we doing to hold those responsible for this to account, including Nobel laureates? Why did we not jointly table, last week, a resolution with Ireland to the United Nations Security Council, despite China and Russia threatening to block it, along with supporting the international calls there for an immediate withdrawal of Eritrean troops from Tigray? Surely this is a prerequisite to ending the depredations in Tigray.

Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon (Con)

My Lords, I agree with the noble Lord that the situation in Tigray is dire. Since the conflict began, the UN Security Council has now discussed Ethiopia on four occasions. During the most recent discussions on 4 March, to which he referred, there was a clear consensus that the situation in Ethiopia, particularly the humanitarian situation, was of deep concern. It is regrettable, as he has pointed out, that certain members of the UN Security Council are continuing to block further discussion, and indeed public discussion, in the current sessions. However, we continue to press for actions in this respect.

Lord Triesman (Lab) [V]

My Lords, I welcome what the Minister has said, but obviously there is more to do. Those of us who were involved in trying to negotiate peace between Ethiopia and Eritrea a decade ago are dismayed by the fact that they are now united, but in the suppression of Tigray. Crimes of concern to humanity are being committed every day and it is no accident that there are highly organised and disciplined militaries on both sides. Can the Minister add to his comments about approaches to the United Nations and tell us what we are doing with the African Union, which can often be a very significant force for installing peace? Can he also comment specifically on the fact that many of the leading Tigrayans who have served in the Ethiopian Government have been absolutely vital to the UK’s interests in securing peace in Somalia and the northern Kenyan regions? They are eager to be in places where they no longer fear for their lives. They want to continue with their education and are keen to continue with their charitable work

The Earl of Courtown (Con)

My Lords, perhaps the noble Lord would curtail his questions and let the Minister answer now.

Lord Triesman (Lab)

I wonder if the Minister would meet me to discuss this.Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon (Con)

My Lords, on the noble Lord’s first question, there are currently no concerted efforts at dialogue between the conflict parties. Regrettably, while I agree with him that the efforts of the AU are important, they have not picked up yet again. We will continue to call for Eritrean troops to leave, and to work with the AU as well as other partners to ensure peace in Tigray.

The Duke of Montrose (Con) [V]

My Lords, I strongly endorse the comments of the two previous noble Lords. In view of the more than three months of communications blackout, along with continuing reports of the killing and rape of civilians, the destruction of harvests and medical facilities, widespread looting and starvation, do Her Majesty’s Government agree that what has taken place in Axum is almost certainly being repeated across Tigray and that there is enough evidence to suspect that ethnic cleansing is taking place in the province? In the light of the adoption by the UK of the responsibility to protect commitment of the 2005 UN World Summit, including paragraphs 138 and 139, what further steps do Her Majesty’s Government plan to take to secure the protection of the Tigrayan population?

Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon (Con)

My Lords, the situation in Tigray is both challenging and dire, as I have just said. Our most recent efforts have included the formation of a joint humanitarian political team from the British embassy, which on 4 and 5 March visited Mekelle, the capital city of Tigray. The team met the provisional administration of Tigray and humanitarian agencies. Our efforts are both political and humanitarian in this respect.

Lord Chidgey (LD) [V]

The reports that several hundred civilians have been massacred in Axum have been confirmed by the Ethiopian Human Rights Commission, contrary to the claims of its own Government. However, within the unfettered access that we apparently now have been granted in the region, will the Government press for evidence of the deliberate destruction of crops and intentional starvation? Will this be a test case for the UN special envoy for famine prevention and humanitarian affairs? Finally, what support are the Government giving Ireland, our closest neighbour in this context and a newly elected member of the UN Security Council, in its campaign to raise the situation in Tigray at the council’s meetings?

Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon (Con)

My Lords, on the noble Lord’s final point, we continue to work with Ireland and indeed, on 15 February, the Foreign Secretary spoke with the Irish Foreign Minister. On the issue of unfettered access, unfortunately, while commitments have been made, that is not the case. Access to Tigray remains very challenging even for humanitarian agencies.

Baroness Kennedy of Cradley (Non-Afl)

My Lords, the 24 Hours for Tigray global lobby started at noon today and either is hearing or is about to hear from young women discussing the trauma of rape being used as a weapon of war. Given the statements in the Amnesty International report about the extent of this war crime, and with International Women’s Day very much in everyone’s mind, what assurances can the noble Lord provide that the many reports about the alleged rape of women in Tigray as part of the war will be taken up and that there will be justice for them?

Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon (Con)

My Lords, as the Prime Minister’s Special Envoy on the Preventing Sexual Violence in Conflict Initiative, I say that this remains a key priority. We are deeply concerned about the credible reports. I was pleased to see the statement from SRSG Pramila Patten showing that teams are already working on the ground collecting evidence to ensure that those who have committed these crimes do not escape punishment.

Lord Grade of Yarmouth (Con) [V]

My Lords, I declare my interest as a founder and current trustee of the Band Aid/Live Aid Trust—hence my interest in the subject. This is clearly a human tragedy. These territories have long been troubled by famine, war, et cetera. What action are the Government considering taking—for example, targeted sanctions, including economic sanctions? There is a lot of talk and discussion, but very little action. Also, does it make complete sense to cut the 0.7% spend on development in the middle of the pandemic, a time when the chair of the G7 should be setting an example? This might help in the region.

Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon (Con)

My Lords, the Government’s response to my noble friend’s second question is already well documented, but I agree that we must ensure change on the ground. He mentioned sanctions and I assure him that we will consider the full range of policy tools at our disposal.

Lord Collins of Highbury (Lab)

My Lords, the Minister said that we must stop people acting with impunity in violating human rights. How are we responding to the call by the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights for an objective independent assessment? Also, how are we working with our allies on the dire humanitarian situation in terms of opening up corridors and getting aid into this very difficult area?

Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon (Con)

My Lords, there is a lot of work being done on the second question that the noble Lord raises, about opening up corridors, but, as I have already said, while declarations have been made, most recently by the Deputy Prime Minister of Ethiopia and the Human Rights Council, including his acceptance that there must be international investigations into allegations, we are yet to see this in practical terms. However, we are working very closely at the HRC, including with the office of the High Commissioner.

Lord Campbell of Pittenweem (LD)

My Lords, does the Minister share my feeling that these dreadful events at Axum are reminiscent of medieval barbarism, involving as they do the deliberate destruction of crops and the pillaging of the hospital and the pharmacy? What international assistance is available to assist this community to rebuild itself?

Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon (Con)

My Lords, the first step, as I am sure the noble Lord agrees, is to help the thousands of internally displaced people. Getting humanitarian access to them in terms of medical supplies and food remains a key priority. I agree that we should then look at medium-term planning, but that cannot come until there is peace in Tigray. On the issue of crops being destroyed, I also know full well that there are also historic sites. The Axum site was an ancient historic city, rich in traditions of faith and in churches that allegedly have also been plundered. So there is a lot to do on the ground, but the priority must be access to Tigray to ensure that civilians get the support that they urgently need.

The Senior Deputy Speaker (Lord McFall of Alcluith)

My Lords, the time allowed for this Question has elapsed.12.53pm

=================================

Three replies to written Questions.

Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon, the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office, has provided the following answer to your written parliamentary question (HL13340):

Question by Lord Alton of Liverpool:
To ask Her Majesty’s Government what assessment they have made of the reports that the government of Ethiopia has transferred military equipment and money to the government of Eritrea in exchange for the engagement of Eritrean soldiers in Tigray. (HL13340)

Tabled on: 22 February 2021

Answer:
Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon:

We are concerned by involvement of Eritrean forces in hostilities throughout the Tigray region of Ethiopia and the growing weight of credible evidence of their involvement in human rights violations. The Minister for Africa has called for their immediate withdrawal, as they are fuelling the conflict. However, we are unable to verify reports that this includes the transfer of military equipment and money by the Government of Ethiopia to the Government of Eritrea. We have raised our concerns with Ministers in both governments, making clear the overriding need to protect civilians and adhere to international law and international human rights law.

Date and time of answer: 09 Mar 2021 at 16:24.

===========================

Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon, the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office, has provided the following answer to your written parliamentary question (HL13341):

Question:
To ask Her Majesty’s Government what assessment they have made of reports (1) that refugee camps in Tigray have been destroyed, (2) that Eritrean refugees are missing as a result, and (3) that Eritrean refugees have been forcibly repatriated to Eritrea. (HL13341)

Tabled on: 22 February 2021

Answer:
Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon:

The UK condemns the destruction of the Hitsats and Shimbella refugee camps in Tigray and calls for urgent assistance to those refugees displaced as a result. We are also concerned at reports that Eritrean troops entered Ethiopian refugee camps in Tigray and forced a number of refugees to return to Eritrea. If proven, this would be a serious violation of the 1951 Refugee Convention. Alleged violations of international law must be investigated as a means to promote respect for legal instruments and to prevent future violations, including as necessary through international criminal tribunals.

The British Ambassador in Eritrea raised these questions with the Eritrean Foreign Minister in December 2020, who denied that Eritrean forces had forcibly returned Eritrean refugees to Eritrea. We are extremely concerned that humanitarian agencies, including the UN High Commission for Refugees (UNHCR), do not have access to refugee camps in Tigray, meaning our understanding of the humanitarian and protection context in camps and refugee hosting areas is limited. It is the responsibility of the host state to ensure refugees are protected and are not subjected to forcible return. This was acknowledged by the Government of Ethiopia when we raised the matter.

Date and time of answer: 09 Mar 2021 at 16:24.

=======================

Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon, the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office, has provided the following answer to your written parliamentary question (HL13554):

Question:
To ask Her Majesty’s Government, what assessment they have made of the decision by the EU to suspend budget support to the government of Ethiopia whilst humanitarian aid workers are unable to access Tigray; and in view of any such assessment, what plans they have to suspend the provision of Official Development Assistance to that government. (HL13554)

Tabled on: 23 February 2021

Answer:
Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon:

We note and understand the decision by the EU to suspend budget support. The UK does not provide general budget support to the Government of Ethiopia. UK Overseas Development Assistance provided to the Government of Ethiopia in the form of financial aid supports the delivery of specific development results; and we track results to ensure our programmes are delivering these life-changing results for Ethiopians in desperate need. UK bilateral ODA spend for Ethiopia in 20/21 is £237m. We work closely with the Government of Ethiopia to ensure and monitor that aid is provided impartially and serves to improve the conditions of intended beneficiaries. We are keeping the provision of aid to Ethiopia under constant review.

Date and time of answer: 09 Mar 2021 at 16:20.

=======================

Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon, the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office, has provided the following answer to your written parliamentary question (HL13555):

Question:
To ask Her Majesty’s Government what steps they are taking to promote the participation of the government of Ethiopia and the Tigray state authorities in peace talks. (HL13555)

Tabled on: 23 February 2021

Answer:
Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon:

We have, and will continue to advocate that a political process is essential to bring a full end to fighting and a sustainable settlement for Tigray. We have consistently urged all parties to end the conflict, prioritise the protection of civilians and allow unfettered humanitarian access. The Foreign Secretary raised these points when he met with Prime Minister Abiy on 22 January and also pressed for a political dialogue to bring a lasting peace to Tigray. The Minister for Africa also pressed for political dialogue to end the conflict when he spoke with the Ethiopian Ambassador on 24 February.

10 comments

  1. I use to think all Western governments are civilized, democrats, impartial and fair when making judgement. I also use to think the British are God fearing men of the Covenant as their name implies. Now I learned the harsh truth that all Western leaders are lie-mongers and bunches of Hippocrats who are only after their selfish interests. They are now conspiring to use the so called ‘Tigray war’ as a pretext to stop the construction of GERD on Abay river, so as to ensure a continius supply of water to Isreal, their creation.
    I’ll not be mistaken if I say that Europeans have been waiting for an oppitunity to vindicate for the crime of inflicting shame on the Italian colonizing force, black Ethiopians had committed 125 yrs ago at the battle of Adwa.

    1. You are completly mistaken! The west are trying to stop the on-going #genocide on #tigreoeople – and thus save the perishing of innocent human lives. Peroid!
      A better ethiopian-ethics for you is to tell #abiy and his pupoetrs – the #amara so called elites – to stop buchering their Ethiopian brotherns!
      Please stop wasting your time to prope fictional-lies.

      A somali-ethiopian bro.

      Tags
      #tigray #ethiopia #tplf #abiyahmed #tesfagiorgis #biden #eu #england #martinplaut #africa #usa #middleeast #addisstandard #eritereahub #ethiopiainsight #tigrepeople #amhara #somali-ethiopians

      1. Very true, those who are supporting the ethnic cleansing in Tigray dont want foteign powers to interfer in Ethiopia. They want to eliminate the people witj no one watching. The first thing they did after the war began was shutting electricity and telephone lines, then then banned journalists to go to Tigray, there were only pro Abiy journalists who went to Tigray to twist onformation and collect information to fool the people.
        Tigreans will not sit back and watch their land being invaded by Ethiopian and Eritrean troops, these troops along with Amhara militia are engagee in raping women, killing people, lootings, burning farmers crops, killing livestocks, destroying factories, mosques, and churches. One of the oldest mosque Alnegashi was hit by these fascists.

    2. You are out of topics, the issue is mainly about humanrights violation and possible war crimes which is committed in Tigray and establishing access to humanitarian aid.

      The people of Tigray are suffering by Eritrean and Ethiopian troops, there are rapings,ass killings lootings and destruction of properties includinf cultural and religious sites.

      The whole world is condemning tje atrocities committed in Tigray except the perpetrators who are suppprting the unelected dictatorial regime of Abiy.

  2. I would like to thank you for your concern.Would you like to see what was happening in the past three years in the other parts of Ethiopia? or you worried only for TPLF ? Sudan and Egypt tries to pressure on Ethiopia Great Ethiopian Renaissance Dam/GERD/ Construction and the second round filling of the water in the coming rainy season of Ethiopia.

    1. Yep. They should be worried too for the gigantic human right violations perperated by autocrate #abiy on the majority of ethiopians – the long marginalized people of #oromo, #somali-ethiopians, the #afars and the souther-peoples.

      Don’t you agree?

      A somali-ethiopian bro

      Tags
      #tigray #ethiopia #tplf #abiyahmed #tesfagiorgis #biden #eu #england #martinplaut #africa #usa #middleeast #addisstandard #eritereahub #ethiopiainsight #tigrepeople #amhara #somali-ethiopians

  3. Considering the full range of policy tools is a must and should be implemented ASAP. Remember, it has been already four months! We, the majority of Ethiopians – the long marginalized people – support and thank you ( Britons ) from our heart for this and for all your other continous humanterian assistance!

    Two other points for your consideration.

    1 – The above consideration should be supplemented by equal actions of your colleaque western nations, particularly the major doner – the US. Same policy-stand from all democratic nations will surely have more effect in stopping this on-going #genocide!

    2 – Not only is a political process essential to a sustainable settlement for Tigray, but to all Ethiopians – especially the long marginalized people. An unimaginable human right violations are perperated in all other regions right this minute. A good example of these atrocities is the gun-point election process forced – by the #abiy stooge ( Mustafe ) on the people of the somali – region. If these atrocities are not addressed in tandem with on-going humanterian aid in #tigreregion, it will be like ‘ drawing water from a well by a bottom-less bucket ‘. All the world efforts will be for nothing and the on-going atrocities will propagate: This time propped by a false election results the world will have headaches to come up with a mandate to tackle with!!!

    Above is a serious matter the west should have in mind!

    1. If you’re a true Somali- Ethiipian, as you claimed yourself to be, you must at least have some common knowledge of the truth of the matter in Tigrai as most real Ethiopian Somalis, H.E.P.Mustefe is one of them, do. Any person who has been following the recent developments in the past four months in Tigrai can easily identity who you are by just reading the two points of recommendations you put forward for your Western masters. The scent of pungent smoke of hatred for the Amhara/Ethiopia hovers all over your words.
      Why do all pro-tplf propagandists cry about human right violations by ethiopian/eritrean soldiers, but never utter even in whisper about the treasonous act of massacre on very large number of soldiers of the federal government, who’re on duty, by the tplf forces? Who among you had the conscience to ask the whereabouts of those prisoners taken by tplf soldiers to be used as human shields and later masacred inhumanly? when are you going to denounce the ethnic cleansing by tplf agents on Amharas in the town of Maikadra?……

      Now that the govt of ethiopia has allowed journalists and humanitarian organizations to enter into Tigrai and find out the truth for themselves by making first hand investigations, rather than buying senseless, politically motivated fabrications and exaggerations? Why are they in a rush to pass sanctiins on ethiopia?
      Hippocrats ! do you think you feel the pain of Ethiopians more than we Ethiopians actually feel it? No! a thousand times no!!! Ethiopians are doing our best to make things right. We’re more than ready to pay the price that has to be paid for our beloved country. We stand with P.Abiy and his government. This is the right time for Western governments to open your eyes and see the fact on the ground. Despite the temporary challenges Ethiopia now faces, She is more democratic than ever. Ethiopia is as good and a reliable partner to Westerners as Isreal or Egypt could be, if not more.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *